Tesla: Insider Sales Raise Questions Amid Ambitious Plans
Among the “Magnificent Seven” tech stocks, Tesla (NASDAQ: TSLA) stands out as the most controversial and fiercely debated.
Since the proliferation of the $TSLAQ hashtag on Twitter, Tesla has attracted both passionate supporters and vocal critics. Early investors who remained steadfast have reaped significant rewards, yet today, the company faces scrutiny due to CEO Elon Musk’s behavior, perceived exaggerations about its autonomous vehicle capabilities, and a high market valuation.
Cathie Wood’s Optimism vs. Caution Among Insiders
A prominent advocate for Tesla is Cathie Wood, CEO of ARK Invest, known for its focus on growth-oriented exchange-traded funds (ETFs). Wood has held Tesla among her largest investments for years and strongly believes in the company’s self-driving strategy. She predicts that Tesla’s robotaxi service will account for the majority of its earnings and value by 2030, and she forecasts a market cap soaring to $7 trillion by 2029.
On the company’s earnings call in October, Musk claimed that autonomy would position Tesla as the world’s most valuable company, “probably by a long shot.”
However, skepticism exists even among those closely connected to the company. In the third quarter, three Tesla insiders implemented 10b5-1 plans, allowing them to sell set amounts of stock at predetermined times. This approach is meant to mitigate any suspicion that insider sales are based on insider information.
Image source: Tesla.
Details on Insider Transactions
The insiders include Board Chair Robyn Denholm, Kimbal Musk (Elon’s brother and director), and Kathleen Wilson-Thompson, a board member since 2018.
Denholm’s plan includes selling up to 674,345 shares, accrued from stock options expiring in June 2025, worth approximately $170 million. Kimbal Musk plans to sell up to 152,088 shares valued at $38 million, with his plan expiring in May 2025. Wilson-Thompson may sell up to 300,000 shares, currently worth $75 million, with her agreement ending in February.
Though insider selling is not uncommon and can occur for various reasons—such as diversification or funding personal projects—the timing of these transactions appears significant, especially considering Tesla’s recent struggles to increase revenue and profits. Production levels of electric vehicles (EVs) have plateaued, coinciding with a broader slowdown in the EV sector.
Despite this, Musk continues to promote Tesla’s autonomous vehicle vision. He recently introduced the Cybercab at a notable event, which has helped maintain the stock’s upward momentum. Questions arise: If a major breakthrough in self-driving technology was imminent, would these insiders still be selling their shares?
What Does This Mean for Tesla Investors?
Insider selling alone does not clearly signal that investors should divest, yet it is an important factor to consider. Tesla’s recent launch of the Cybercab marks a strategic move, with hopes to deploy them in Texas and California by 2025 and potentially escalating production to millions by 2026. However, significant regulatory challenges remain for deploying autonomous vehicles without conventional controls.
Currently, the National Highway Transportation Safety Administration (NHTSA) restricts the rollout of such vehicles to 2,500 annually. Hence, Tesla must prove its technology’s safety and advocate for looser regulations to fulfill Musk’s ambitious vision.
Political dynamics might also influence Tesla’s trajectory, especially with Musk’s endorsement of the Trump campaign. Concerns over the stock’s future if Vice President Kamala Harris assumes the presidency may be additional rationales guiding insider sales amidst the stock’s lofty price-to-earnings ratio, which exceeds 100.
While Tesla has the potential to evolve into a trillion-dollar enterprise with a vast robotaxi network, the recent profit surge following its third-quarter earnings and the inconsistent growth over the previous quarters suggest that locking in profits could be wise for long-term shareholders.
Where to Invest $1,000 Right Now
Insights from our analyst team can prove valuable. As of now, Stock Advisor’s total average return stands at 816%, a remarkable performance compared to the S&P 500’s 167%.*
They’ve identified the 10 best stocks for investors to consider right now, including Tesla—but other promising opportunities may be flying under your radar.
See the 10 stocks »
*Stock Advisor returns as of October 28, 2024
Jeremy Bowman has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has positions in and recommends Tesla. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.
The views and opinions expressed herein are the views and opinions of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of Nasdaq, Inc.
