Upstart Holdings Struggles Amid Economic Challenges and Volatile Stock Performance

Upstart Holdings (NASDAQ: UPST), an AI-driven lending platform, is facing a significant stock decline. Shares have dropped more than 55% from highs near $90 in February, now trading below $40. For investors, this moment feels reminiscent of the company’s staggering 96% plunge during the inflation crisis of 2022. For those seeking a more stable investment than individual stocks, the High-Quality portfolio has notably outperformed the S&P 500, boasting returns greater than 91% since its inception.

Understanding Upstart’s Challenges

Upstart’s business model, which connects borrowers to lenders via its AI technology, faces inherent challenges, particularly related to interest rate fluctuations. Higher interest rates tend to suppress loan demand, which directly affects the company’s revenue.

This vulnerability has become clear in Upstart’s recent financial outcomes:

• Revenue Decline: Over the past three years, Upstart’s revenue has decreased at an average rate of 5.5% due to the persistently high-interest rate climate.
• Recent Recovery: However, with the Federal Reserve beginning its rate cut cycle, revenues have surged, rising 24% over the last year to reach $629 million, including an impressive 57% growth in the most recent quarter.
• Profitability Struggles: Despite the rise in revenues, Upstart has faced ongoing profitability issues, reporting an operating loss of $128 million over the last four quarters, resulting in a troubling -20.4% operating margin.

Examining Upstart’s financial health reveals a complex picture:

• Cash Flow Strength: One positive aspect is Upstart’s operating cash flow, which reached $186 million in the last four quarters, yielding a solid OCF-to-Sales ratio of 30%.
• Balance Sheet Concerns: However, its $1.5 billion debt compared to a market capitalization of $3.6 billion results in a high Debt-to-Equity ratio of 39%, indicating significant leverage.
• Liquidity Buffer: Conversely, Upstart maintains robust liquidity, holding $794 million in cash and equivalents, which makes up 33% of its total assets valued at $2.4 billion.

Macroeconomic Factors Affecting Upstart

Multiple external factors pose near-term challenges for Upstart:

• Tariff Concerns: Rising tariffs and trade tensions heighten the risk of economic instability, potentially reducing loan demand and pressuring Upstart’s operations.
• Inflation Risks: Ongoing trade conflicts may reignite inflation, complicating the Federal Reserve’s rate-cutting strategies and maintaining elevated borrowing costs longer than expected.
• Credit Quality: As economic conditions worsen, loan defaults could increase, which would adversely affect Upstart’s appeal to lenders as well as its loan portfolio performance.

Valuation and Future Outlook

Currently, Upstart trades at 5.5 times its trailing revenue, which is a premium over the S&P 500 index’s average of 2.8 times but aligns with Upstart’s three-year average price-to-sales ratio. This suggests that the market continues to factor in significant growth expectations, despite the challenging circumstances faced by the company.

Although Upstart’s stock shows a considerable discount from previous highs, caution is warranted. The combination of macroeconomic uncertainties, ongoing profitability challenges, and elevated valuation multiples hints at a limited margin of safety for investors.

The recent uptick in revenue illustrates that Upstart’s AI-driven lending approach can succeed in favorable economic conditions. Yet, this model remains susceptible to downturns and credit market disruptions.

For prospective investors, the key question lies not in Upstart’s capability to thrive in optimal conditions—it has demonstrated that ability—but in its resilience to withstand inevitable economic fluctuations without the severe instability that has characterized its stock performance thus far.

Hanging on to a declining stock can be challenging. One firm addressing these difficulties is Trefis, in collaboration with Empirical Asset Management—a Boston-based wealth manager known for delivering positive returns even during the 2008/2009 financial crisis, when the S&P 500 fell over 40%.

Empirical has incorporated the Trefis HQ Portfolio into its asset allocation strategy, allowing clients to achieve superior returns with reduced risk compared to benchmark indices. This reduces the volatility often associated with traditional stock investments, as demonstrated by HQ Portfolio performance metrics.

As investors hope for a smooth economic landing, the upcoming challenges of another recession raise concerns. Explore the last six market crashes compared.

Invest with Trefis Market-Beating Portfolios
Discover all Trefis Price Estimates