How Potential Payroll Tax Changes Could Impact Social Security

In 2025, workers will contribute 6.2% of their first $176,100 in earnings toward Social Security payroll taxes. For self-employed individuals, this rate is even higher. Given this significant impact on annual income, it’s understandable if many people oppose raising payroll taxes to maintain Social Security’s financial stability.

However, the reality is that the Social Security program is less than ten years away from being unable to pay all scheduled benefits. If we want to avoid reduced checks during retirement, Congress must identify strategies to boost Social Security’s income. While higher payroll taxes may be a part of the solution, the implications might not be as painful as expected for various reasons.

Targeted Tax-Increasing Proposals Focus on High Earners

Currently, high-income earners do not pay Social Security taxes on earnings exceeding $176,100, which many consider inequitable. Various proposals suggest raising or eliminating this cap to ensure that wealthy individuals contribute more to the program.

The specific outcomes of such proposals vary. If Congress were to subject all earnings to the existing payroll tax, it could potentially close about 53% of Social Security’s estimated funding shortfall. Moreover, implementing a tax on high earners without a corresponding increase in benefits could eliminate up to 73% of the estimated deficit.

Although neither scenario would fully resolve Social Security’s projected shortfall, significant progress could be made. Such reforms would also lessen the necessary payroll tax increases needed to keep the program viable.

Most Workers Share Social Security Payroll Tax Burden

The current Social Security payroll tax rate stands at 12.4%, a figure equally split between employer and employee for traditional employees. Meanwhile, self-employed individuals shoulder the full 12.4% but can deduct half of their self-employment tax payments.

Since the majority of workers do not bear the entire Social Security tax burden, they will not face the full impact of potential tax increases. For instance, if the government increases the tax rate by one percentage point, most employees would only be responsible for half of this additional charge.

Tax Increases May Be Part of Broader Reforms

Increasing payroll taxes is only one of several strategies proposed for addressing Social Security’s funding crisis. Other suggested reforms might include:

• Raising the full retirement age (currently 67 for most workers)
• Reducing benefits for some or all retirees
• Implementing a separate tax on investment income to help finance the program

By introducing one or more of these strategies, the government could further reduce the tax increases necessary to maintain Social Security’s financial health.

While it is still uncertain what direction Congress will choose, there currently appears to be no immediate need for concern about substantial tax increases. Once a bill is closer to approval that reforms Social Security, it will be the right moment to examine how those changes could affect individual budgets.

The $22,924 Social Security Bonus Many Retirees Overlook

Like many Americans, you might be behind on your retirement savings. Fortunately, some lesser-known “Social Security secrets” can enhance your retirement income. For instance, one simple strategy might boost your annual income by as much as $22,924. By maximizing your Social Security benefits, you could retire with greater confidence and peace of mind. Simply click here to discover more about these valuable strategies.

View the “Social Security secrets” »

The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.

The views and opinions expressed herein are the views and opinions of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of Nasdaq, Inc.