Insure.com Reveals 2025 Rankings of Top Insurance Companies

Annual rankings find Travelers, Nationwide, Amica, State Farm, Kaiser Permanente, and Northwestern Mutual among the top insurers

Insure.com has announced its Best Insurance Companies for 2025 rankings, representing the 13th consecutive year the site—an extensive resource for insurance insights—has evaluated leading auto, home, life, and health insurers.

The complete report can be accessed here: Best insurance companies of 2025

Top Insurers in the Industry

Some of the standout insurers include:

Best car insurance company: Travelers
Best car insurance company for cheap rates: Nationwide
Best car insurance company for customer satisfaction: Amica
Best home insurance company: Amica
Best home insurance company for policy offerings: Nationwide
Best for auto and home bundling: Nationwide
Best life insurance company: Northwestern Mutual
Best health insurance companies: Kaiser Permanente and UnitedHealthcare (tied)

Methodology Behind the Rankings

Insure.com’s editorial team utilized various data sources to create these rankings. Their process included a survey of nearly 2,000 insurance consumers to evaluate factors such as customer experience, claims handling, trustworthiness, and digital experiences. In addition to consumer feedback, they analyzed insurers’ rate information, AM Best financial stability scores, and complaint records from the National Association of Insurance Commissioners.

Top Five Companies by Insurance Category

Auto Insurance:

1. Travelers
2. Nationwide
3. Geico
4. State Farm
5. Progressive

Home Insurance:

1. Amica
2. State Farm
3. Allstate
4. Progressive
5. Nationwide

Health Insurance:

1. Kaiser Permanente and UnitedHealthcare (tie)
3. Aetna
4. Highmark
5. Elevance, HCSC, and Humana (tie)

Life Insurance:

1. Northwestern Mutual
2. MassMutual
3. New York Life and John Hancock (tie)
5. Prudential

Expert Insights

“The intention behind the Best Insurance Companies rankings is to provide consumers with insights on which insurer might best meet their needs and budget,” stated Nupur Gambhir, managing editor of Insure.com and a licensed insurance agent. “With rising insurance costs, it’s crucial for consumers to shop around and compare options for price, coverage, and other factors. Our rankings offer a reliable starting point.”

Gambhir is available for interviews to discuss the findings and emerging trends influencing consumer insurance preferences.

About Insure.com

Insure.com operates under QuinStreet, Inc. QNST, a leader in performance marketplace technologies for financial services and home services. QuinStreet connects searchers with brands through innovative online marketplace solutions. The company aims to empower consumers with comprehensive tools to research and select the insurance products and brands that best serve their needs. Insure.com has been a trusted consumer resource for insurance information for over two decades, offering expert advice and tools across various insurance types.