Bitcoin Options: Evaluating iShares Bitcoin Trust vs. Strategy
Bitcoin (CRYPTO: BTC) remains the leading cryptocurrency. Despite some volatility earlier in the year, Bitcoin’s price has increased by over 9% since January and surged more than 60% in the past year.
Incorporating Bitcoin into a diversified portfolio can be beneficial. There are various ways to invest in Bitcoin without needing to purchase or manage actual coins.
Investment Options: iShares Bitcoin Trust ETF vs. Strategy
The iShares Bitcoin Trust ETF (NASDAQ: IBIT) and Strategy (NASDAQ: MSTR), previously known as MicroStrategy, have both performed well in recent years. However, the question remains: which offers better value today?
Understanding Strategy’s Performance
It’s crucial to differentiate between these two investment vehicles. The iShares Bitcoin Trust ETF is a spot Bitcoin ETF, which means it purchases and holds Bitcoin on behalf of investors. Its goal is to mirror Bitcoin’s market price, minus fees. This structure allows investors to buy or sell Bitcoin like any other stock through the ETF.
Conversely, Strategy is a publicly traded company initially involved in enterprise software and consulting that has shifted focus to accumulate Bitcoin as capital in a digital economy. As of May 5, Strategy owned 555,450 Bitcoins. At the current price of just under $103,000, this amounts to approximately $57.2 billion—nearly half of Strategy’s market cap of $113 billion.
Both investments have seen gains alongside Bitcoin’s ascent, but Strategy’s increase has been exceptional. Its shares have soared over 670% since 2023, surpassing both Bitcoin and the iShares Bitcoin Trust ETF:
IBIT Total Return Level data by YCharts
Is Strategy’s Dominance Sustainable?
While Strategy’s software component contributes roughly $5 billion to its total market cap, the bulk of its value is tied to its Bitcoin holdings. If Strategy’s stock price correlates with Bitcoin’s, that could work in its favor. Currently, the iShares Bitcoin Trust ETF trades just 0.21% above its net asset value. In contrast, Strategy trades at about a 118% premium.
This disparity raises concerns. For each share of Strategy, there is $190 in Bitcoin, yet the stock trades at $416. A significant drop in this premium could have drastic effects.
Why are investors willing to pay such a high price for Strategy’s stock? Its impressive past performance often attracts more investors. Additionally, Strategy’s ongoing accumulation of Bitcoin, with plans to monetize it, may draw interest. However, this remains more of a vision than a solid business model, especially as Strategy reported losses in Q1 2025.
Making the Investment Decision
Worsening the situation, Strategy frequently issues new stock and convertible bonds to fund its Bitcoin purchases. This strategy, supported by Bitcoin reserves, poses risks if Bitcoin prices decline. Such fluctuations could force the company to liquidate its holdings or dilute shares by issuing new stock.
This cycle of raising funds at higher prices may have driven Strategy’s stock to tremendous gains, but it also harbors risks of significant losses as market conditions change. The pitfalls of leveraged strategies can be substantial.
Bitcoin has historically proven a strong investment. Given the elevated risks associated with Strategy’s premium valuation relative to its Bitcoin assets, many investors may find the iShares Bitcoin Trust ETF a more stable and preferable option.
Investment in iShares Bitcoin Trust: A Safer Choice?
Before committing to stock in iShares Bitcoin Trust, consider the following:
The Motley Fool Stock Advisor analyst team recently identified their top 10 stocks for investment, none of which included iShares Bitcoin Trust. The selections made could yield substantial returns over the coming years.
For example, when Netflix was recommended on December 17, 2004, a $1,000 investment would now be worth $614,911!*
Similarly, an investment in Nvidia recommended on April 15, 2005 would now equal $714,958!*
The total average return for Stock Advisor is 907%, significantly surpassing the 163% gain of the S&P 500.
*Stock Advisor returns as of May 12, 2025
Justin Pope has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has positions in and recommends Bitcoin. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.
The views and opinions expressed herein are the views and opinions of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of Nasdaq, Inc.
