While the market is experiencing fear, savvy investors might find a buying opportunity. The latest AAII Sentiment Survey has shown a contrarian Buy signal, as bullish sentiment has fallen to its lowest point since the S&P 500‘s bottom in November 2023.

Historically, when extreme pessimism appears, it often leads to significant market gains. For investors in the SPDR S&P 500 ETF SPY, this moment could signal a time to invest.

Understanding the Bearish Sentiment

The AAII survey reveals that only 25.4% of investors are feeling bullish, which is well below the historical average of 37.5%. On the other hand, bearish sentiment has surged to 40.6%, reaching its highest level in a year. When investors exhibit such fear, market bottoms frequently follow, creating a compelling contrarian buying opportunity.

For SPY investors, this environment suggests that these extreme indicators could mark a turning point in the market. However, mixed signals from technical indicators present a challenge for those attempting to time their next investment move.

Read Also: US Stocks Expected to Rise Ahead of Trump’s Inauguration: Analysts Predict Profit Growth Across All Sectors by 2025

SPY’s Current Technical Landscape

After a robust performance this past year with a 25.3% increase, SPY’s more recent actions indicate a pause.

Chart created using Benzinga Pro

Currently trading around $591.64, SPY remains above key moving averages, suggesting a bullish trend. Nevertheless, emerging signs of selling pressure warrant attention:

• Short-term strength: The eight-day and 20-day moving averages indicate a bullish trend that supports a potential increase.
• Long-term caution: SPY is trading below its 50-day moving average of $595.08, signaling potential weakness ahead.
• MACD (moving average convergence/divergence) indicates caution: With a negative 1.95 reading, momentum indicators suggest a possible slowdown in market momentum.
• RSI (relative strength index) at 50.11: This reading shows that SPY is not overbought or oversold, indicating it is at a critical juncture.

Final Thoughts: One Must Consider Fear vs. Caution

The AAII survey shows growing pessimism among investors, marking a potential turning point that could signal growth. Yet, as SPY trades near its historical highs and with technical indicators sending mixed signals, investors face a critical decision between optimism and caution.

For contrarians, this may present a perfect entry point. Conversely, waiting for clearer technical indicators might prove to be the wiser choice.

Read Next:

Photo: Shutterstock